Investors love the thrill of the chase. The idea of consistently beating the market gets hearts racing and headlines buzzing. But let’s pause here for a moment. Does chasing elusive “alpha” really pay off in the long run, or is it just a costly distraction from what truly matters—capturing the market return, or what we call “beta”?
The reality, borne out by decades of data, is that simply being in the market—capturing beta—will likely get you further than trying to outsmart it. It’s not glamorous. It’s not going to land you on the cover of Forbes. But as any long-term investor knows, the market’s return is more than good enough for your money to grow, and the best part? You don’t have to play hero to get it.
I call this the participation trophy. And trust me, it’s the trophy you actually want.
The Power of Market Beta: Growth of $1,000 in the S&P 500
Let’s take a look at the S&P 500, the closest thing we have to a crystal ball for American capitalism. If you invested $1,000 in the S&P 500 back in 1970, and kept your hands off that money (because you’re not a market timer, right?), you’d be sitting on about $216,000 today. That’s the power of market beta—steady, boring, but immensely profitable.
What did you need to do to earn that? Nothing except patience and endurance (staying invested for the long haul). No stock-picking brilliance, no market-timing wizardry. Just allowing capitalism and compounding do their thing.
Source: Official S&P 500 data.
The Active Management Myth: Why Most Fail to Outperform
Now, if you were to tell me, “Sure, John, but I’m not satisfied with just market returns. I want to beat it!” I’d remind you of this: most professionals can’t. And they get paid a lot to try.
According to the SPIVA (S&P Indices Versus Active) report, over 90% of actively managed large-cap funds underperform the S&P 500 over a 15-year stretch. That’s 90% of the best and brightest, the people with all the Bloomberg terminals, models, and PhDs, most unable to beat a simple index over time. And let’s not even get started on what happens after you factor in fees and taxes.
Markets Are Efficient—Deal With It
Why does this happen? Because markets, despite what stock-picking enthusiasts will tell you, are pretty darn efficient. Information moves fast. Like, really fast. Quicker than you can hit “buy” or “sell.” The second some juicy earnings data or economic report comes out, it’s already in the price. You’re not smarter than the collective wisdom of millions of market participants, many of whom have more resources and speed than you do.
The market isn’t dumb. It’s ruthlessly effective at sniffing out mispricing and closing those gaps. Could you get lucky? Sure. But here’s the rub: Luck isn’t a strategy, and repeating it over a lifetime of investing is near impossible.
The Grind: Why Outperformance Isn’t Just Hard—It’s Exhausting
Let’s be clear. It’s not that picking a winning stock is impossible. Plenty of people do it. The hard part is doing it again. And again. Over decades. Even more daunting is doing it while managing fund flows, tax implications, and transaction costs that eat away at every percentage point of return.
Taxes, in particular, are the silent killer. Every time you trade, there’s a tax bill waiting for you. Those who say you can beat the market and stay tax-efficient are essentially promising to find a unicorn—one that’s also great at accounting. And while they’re looking for that, the passive investor is quietly compounding wealth in low-cost, tax-efficient index funds.
The Challenge of Staying in the Market: The Noise and Volatility Trap
Let’s add another layer to this challenge: staying in the market. You’d think capturing market beta would be easy—just stay invested and let the market work its magic. But here’s the kicker: Most investors can’t handle it.
Why? Because markets are volatile and noisy. The financial media is constantly blasting “breaking news” about the latest recession fears, stock crashes, or trade wars. Every headline seems designed to make you panic, and every market dip looks like the beginning of the end. The reality is, volatility is part of the deal. The investment made in the S&P 500 didn’t go from $1,000 to $216,000 without plenty of scary moments along the way.
Staying in the market through all that noise takes discipline. It’s easy to get shaken out when things look bleak, but it’s the investors who hold on—those who ride out the storms—who end up benefiting from the market’s long-term growth. In other words, the real challenge isn’t just capturing beta; it’s having the guts to stick with it.
LDI: Staying Invested Without Selling for Expenses
One of the best strategies to ensure you can capture market beta over the long term without getting derailed by volatility or needing to sell at the worst times is through a Liability-Driven Investing (LDI) approach. By matching your essential expenses—like housing, healthcare, and lifestyle costs—with safe, income-generating assets, you don’t have to sell your riskier investments to fund your life when the market dips.
LDI ensures you have a “lifestyle floor” that covers your basic needs, often through bonds or other income-generating assets that match the timing of your expenses. This way, you’re free to leave the rest of your portfolio—the riskier, growth-focused part—fully invested in the market to capture beta. And most importantly, you won’t be forced to sell equities during a downturn just to pay the bills.
By separating out your needs (covered by safe assets) and your wants (covered by growth assets), LDI lets you ride out market volatility without needing to panic-sell when prices drop. It’s an essential strategy for any long-term investor who wants to stay in the game while sleeping soundly at night.
Chasing Alpha: The Real Cost
Let’s talk costs. Active management is expensive. There are management fees, transaction costs, taxes, and—perhaps most costly—missed opportunity. Every time an active manager makes a move, they have to be right not just once, but twice: when to buy and when to sell. Over time, those errors and frictions pile up. The end result? A significant drag on performance, and less money in your pocket.
Meanwhile, capturing market beta through an index fund costs you next to nothing. You don’t need to spend your days chasing elusive alpha when market beta is sitting right there, available for a fraction of the cost.
Conclusion: Market Beta Is the Real Trophy
The lesson here isn’t complicated. The biggest determinant of your long-term investment success is exposure to the market. Trying to outguess the market is a losing game for most investors. But if you can secure market beta cheaply, tax-efficiently, and without overthinking things, you’re already winning.
So yes, I’m here to tell you that the participation trophy is the one you want. Be in the market. Capture its beta. Stay calm through the inevitable noise and volatility. And let the alpha chasers exhaust themselves while you quietly grow your wealth.
John Grubbs, CAIA®, AAMS®
The SPIVA report, or S&P Indices Versus Active report, is an ongoing study published by S&P Dow Jones Indices that compares the performance of actively managed funds to their corresponding benchmark indices. Essentially, it tracks how well professional fund managers—those running mutual funds or other actively managed vehicles—perform against benchmarks like the S&P 500.
The report is widely cited because it consistently shows that most active managers underperform their benchmark over long periods of time, particularly after fees are taken into account. The data is available across various asset classes, time horizons, and geographies, providing insight into the persistent difficulties that active managers face in trying to outperform the broader market.
You can access the latest SPIVA report directly from S&P Dow Jones Indices through this link to the SPIVA U.S. Scorecard.
Disclosures:
Past performance is not indicative of future results. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Any references to historical returns, financial projections, or expected results are based on assumptions and are not guarantees. Market conditions, economic events, and other factors can significantly impact investment outcomes, and no investment strategy can assure profitability.
All information is provided in this publication for informational and educational purposes only, and in no way is any of the content herein to be construed as financial, investment, or legal advice or instruction. Meridian Wealth Management, LLC does not guarantee the quality, accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information in this publication. While efforts are made to verify the information provided, the information should not be assumed to be error free. Information in the publication may have been provided by third parties and has not necessarily been verified by Meridian Wealth Management, LLC and does not assume any liability for the information contained herein, be it direct, indirect, consequential, special, or exemplary, or other damages whatsoever and howsoever caused, arising out of or in connection with the use of this publication or in reliance on the information, including any personal or pecuniary loss, whether the action is in contract, tor (including negligence) or other tortious action.
Meridian Wealth Management, LLC, dba Meridian Wealth Management is a Registered Investment Advisor in the State of Washington and certain other states. The advisor may not transact business in states where it is not appropriately registered, excluded or exempted for registration. Individualized responses to persons that involve either the effecting of transactions in securities, or rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation will not be made without registration or exemption.
